Guitar Maintenance & Repair

Guitar Tuning Peg Not Tightening Strings? Here’s What To Do

By · 9 min read

acoustic guitar | Sandy Music Lab

Tuning a guitar is second nature to seasoned musicians. But what happens when the tuning process only leads to more pitchiness? Luckily, there are plenty of ways to fix this problem.

Quick answer: If a tuning peg will not tighten the string, first snug the screw in the end of the tuner button (a quarter turn at a time), then the 10 mm bushing nut on the front of the headstock, then the small rear screw. If the string still slips, restring it with two to four neat wraps starting on the side of the post opposite the button. Worn gears that skip need a new tuner.

If your guitar tuning peg is not tightening strings, identify the problem first. Common issues include a faulty tuning mechanism, poorly wound strings, or strings wound in the wrong direction. If none of these causes apply, it is time to seek a professional repair person’s help.

Read on to learn how you can fix your guitar’s tuning issues. If none of these solutions work, keep reading to learn how to find a quality guitar repair person.

Related: 6 reasons why your acoustic guitar strings buzz. New to this topic? Start with our complete guitar maintenance and cleaning guide.

Most Common Tuning Peg Issues

Fixing tuning pegs that refuse to tighten strings is an easy process as long as you can diagnose the problem. For your convenience, we gathered some of the most common causes, along with some how-to fixing guides below.

Why Won’t My Tuning Peg Tighten the String?

Work out which of these is happening before you touch anything. Most tuning peg problems are a loose screw or a badly wound string, not a dead tuner.

What you noticeLikely causeFix
Button spins freely and the string does not tightenLoose or stripped button screw, or worn gearsTighten the button screw; replace the tuner if the gears skip
Button wobbles, or the whole tuner shifts or rattlesLoose bushing nut or rear mounting screwSnug the 10 mm bushing nut and the small rear screw
String goes flat soon after you tune itString slipping on the post, ball end not seated, or too many or too few wrapsRestring with neat wraps and stretch the string
Turning the button the normal way loosens the stringString is wound on the wrong side of the postRestring starting on the side opposite the button
Tuner is very hard to turnButton screw or bushing nut is too tightBack off a quarter turn
Clicks or skips under tensionWorn gears inside the tunerReplace the tuner

How Do You Tighten a Loose Guitar Tuning Peg?

Do these in order, and keep each adjustment snug, never forced.

  1. Button screw. Most tuners have a small Phillips screw in the end of the button. Turn it a quarter turn at a time until the button turns smoothly with slight resistance. Too tight makes the tuner hard to turn, and too loose lets it slip or buzz.
  2. Front bushing nut. Use a 10 mm open-end wrench or socket (not pliers) and turn clockwise until the tuner stops moving. You can do this with the strings on. Wood shrinks in dry air, so these nuts often loosen over time.
  3. Rear screw. Snug the small screw on the back of the headstock that stops the tuner from rotating. If it just spins, the hole is stripped. Remove it, push in a toothpick with wood glue, let it dry, trim it flush and refit the screw.
  4. Vintage-style tuners with press-in bushings and no nut can come loose in the headstock. That is a quick job for a tech rather than something to force.

Classical guitars with slotted headstocks use the same geared tuners and the same fixes. The string is tied off at the post, so a loose knot is another common cause of slipping.

How Do You Wind a String So It Does Not Slip?

Many “tuning peg not tightening” problems are really string winding problems:

  1. Start the string on the side of the post opposite the tuner button, then wind downward so each wrap sits below the last and none overlap. This is also why a string wound on the wrong side tunes backwards.
  2. Leave roughly 2 to 3 in (50 to 75 mm) of slack past the post before you wind, so you get enough wraps.
  3. Use about two to four neat wraps on a non-locking post. Too many wraps stack up and slip, and too few can pull loose.
  4. On an acoustic, seat the ball end in the bridge by pulling gently on the string with the bridge pin held down, or the string will creep flat for days.
  5. Stretch each string gently, retune, and repeat a few times until the pitch holds. A locking tuner needs only about a half wrap.

If tuning still drifts, the nut may be binding the strings. Our guide to the best guitar nut lubricants covers that, and our full guide to changing guitar strings shows the whole restringing process.

When Do You Need a New Tuner?

If the post turns but the string will not hold pitch, or you feel the gear skip under tension, the teeth are worn and no screw will fix it. Replace the tuner, and match the post hole size, the mounting screw position and the layout before you buy. Locking tuners are a worthwhile upgrade if they fit your headstock, and we compare them in our guide to the best locking tuners for guitar.

When Should You Take It to a Repair Person?

Take the guitar to a tech if the gears are worn or broken, a bushing or the headstock wood is cracked, a screw hole is too stripped to repair, or you have tried the steps above and the tuning still will not hold. Ask the shop to explain what is wrong and what the repair costs before they start, and check recent reviews.

Final Thoughts On Guitar Tuning Peg Not Tightening Strings

In short, if your guitar’s tuning pegs do not tighten the strings, there is either a problem with the tuning mechanism or the strings themselves (here’s how to keep a guitar tuning peg from slipping). Tuning mechanism issues usually require some adjustments using standard hardware. Incorrectly wound strings need you to restring the guitar. Unfortunately, there are some tuning problems that a musician cannot solve on their own. In this case, it is vital to seek help from a professional guitar repair person.

FAQs On Guitar Tuning Peg Not Tightening Strings

How do you fix a loose guitar tuning peg?

To fix a loose guitar tuning peg, you may need to tighten the screw that holds the peg in place, or replace the bushing that fits into the peg hole in the headstock. You can also try applying a small amount of wood glue to the peg and letting it dry before reinserting it into the hole.

How do you fix a guitar string that won’t tighten?

If a guitar string won’t tighten, it may be due to a problem with the tuning peg or the nut slot. Check to make sure the string is properly inserted into the peg and that the peg is securely tightened. If the problem persists, you may need to file the nut slot or replace the tuning peg.

How do I know if my tuning pegs are bad?

Signs that your tuning pegs may be bad include difficulty tuning the guitar, loose or wobbly pegs, or a clicking or popping sound when turning the pegs. If you suspect that your tuning pegs are bad, it may be time to replace them.

How do you fix tuning pegs?

To fix tuning pegs, you may need to tighten the screw that holds the peg in place, replace the bushing that fits into the peg hole in the headstock, or lubricate the gears inside the peg with a small amount of graphite or other lubricant. If the pegs are severely damaged or worn, it may be necessary to replace them entirely.

Are tuning pegs supposed to be loose?

Tuning pegs should not be loose, as this can cause tuning instability and affect the playability of the guitar. If your tuning pegs are loose, you may need to tighten the screw that holds them in place or replace the bushing that fits into the peg hole in the headstock.

Should tuning pegs be tight?

Tuning pegs should be tight enough to hold the strings in tune, but not so tight that they are difficult to turn or become damaged. If your tuning pegs are too loose or too tight, it may affect the playability and tuning stability of your guitar.

Why are my guitar strings loose but in tune?

If your guitar strings are loose but in tune, it may be due to a problem with the tuning peg or the nut slot. Check to make sure the string is properly inserted into the peg and that the peg is securely tightened. If the problem persists, you may need to file the nut slot or replace the tuning peg.

Why do my guitar strings keep untuning and coming loose?

Guitar strings may become untuned and come loose if there is a problem with the tuning pegs, the nut slot, or the bridge. Check to make sure that the strings are properly inserted and tightened, and that the tuning pegs are securely in place. If the problem persists, it may be necessary to replace or repair the affected components.

How do you fix a loose tuner bushing?

To fix a loose tuner bushing, you may need to remove the tuning peg and replace the bushing with a new one that fits snugly in the headstock hole. You can also try applying a small amount of wood glue to the bushing and letting it dry before reinserting the peg.

Why does my tuning peg keep clicking?

A clicking sound when turning a tuning peg may be due to a problem with the gears inside the peg. You can try lubricating the gears with a small amount of graphite or other lubricant to see if this helps. If the problem persists, it may be necessary to replace the affected tuning peg.

How do you make strings tighter?

To make strings tighter, you can turn the tuning pegs in the direction that tightens the string, typically clockwise. Be careful not to overtighten the strings, as this can cause damage to the guitar or strings. It’s also important to ensure that the string is properly seated in the tuning peg and that the peg is securely tightened.

How long do guitar tuning pegs last?

The lifespan of guitar tuning pegs can vary depending on factors such as usage frequency and maintenance. Generally, high-quality tuning pegs can last for many years or even decades with proper care and maintenance.

When should I replace my tuning peg?

You may need to replace your tuning pegs if they become worn, damaged, or loose, or if they no longer hold the strings in tune. If you notice tuning instability or difficulty tuning your guitar, it may be time to consider replacing the tuning pegs.

Related Posts: